Charter

A general outline      The right to protection against exploitation
   Rights and Freedoms    Right
Discrimination Risk factors
Procedure of investigation How the Commission proceeds


 
How the Commission proceeds with exploitation complaints

In all cases, whenever it deems it to be appropriate, the Commission conducts an investigation. In the course of such investigation, it may discover that:
  • The victim is "incapable": in that case, the Commission refers the matter to the Public Curator and proceeds with the help of its partners (CLSC, Curator, ...).
     
  • The victim is deemed to be "capable": there are two possibilities in this case:
     
    • If the victim agrees to an intervention, the Commission proceeds with its investigation and suggests measures aimed at stopping the ongoing abuse;
       
    • If the victim does not agree, knowingly, to an intervention by the Commission, the Charter implies that the Commission must respect that person's fundamental right to self-determination, as long as the safety of that person is not at risk.
The Commission then makes sure that the safety of that person is not at risk, by, among other things, organizing measures, in co-operation with organizations capable of adequately monitoring the situation (CLSC personnel) or putting an end to the situation (e.g. police).


Who can make a complaint in matters of exploitation?

The victim herself or himself, or a victims' group;

An organisation dedicated to the defence of rights and freedoms or the well-being of a specific group* (users' committee);

Any person witnesses a situation (family member, friend, neighbour, volunteer worker or other) may report it to the Commission;

The Commission may also investigate on its own initiative.
*No legal obligation but a moral responsibility

Prevention: one of the best ways to protect elder persons against exploitation

  • Information
    The elder person must be aware of the consequences of exploitation, of its manifestations, of the various ways and means at his disposal in cases of abuse.
     
  • Support of the community
    The support of the community increases the chances of avoiding situations that could make a person vulnerable to exploitation.
     
Complaints processed by the Commission in 2001, 2002 and 2003

2003
  • 155 requests of investigations under elder exploitation on a total of 1995;
     
  • Cases were settled through joint actions with other organizations, before even a formal investigation began; some cases were refused and others were abandoned by the complainant;
     
  • 54 investigations (6% of the total of 906) dealt with elder abuse. 

2002

  • 98 requests of investigations under elder exploitation on a total of 2081;
     
  • Cases were settled through joint actions with other organizations, before even a formal investigation began; some cases were refused and others were abandoned by the complainant;
     
  • 33 investigations (3,4% of the total of 970) dealt with elder abuse. 

2001

  • 50 requests of investigations under elder exploitation on a total of 2332;
     
  • Cases were settled through joint actions with other organizations, before even a formal investigation began; some cases were refused and others were abandoned by the complainant;
     
  • 26 investigations (2,4% of the total of 1058) dealt with elder abuse.

Five decisions of the Tribunal des droits de la personne

Five cases of aged person exploitation have been referred to the Tribunal des droits de la personne and the Commission won all cases.
  • the Hamel case, in 2003;
  • the Vallée case, in 2003 (* in appeal); 
  • the Gagné case, in 2002
  • the Fiset case, in 1998
  • the Brzozowski case, in 1994
     

Note: An important case of exploitation of handicapped persons is the Coutu case, in 1995.




Questions and comments
Rights and Freedoms for All Ages | Elder persons | Charter | Participate
Publications | Links | Back to CDPDJ
© 2000-2001 and 2004 Commission des droits de la personne et des droits de la jeunesse.